The SEC’s Private Fund Adviser Rule: Investor Protection and Industry Impact

Paul Balynsky

In a significant move to safeguard private fund investors and promote transparency in the rapidly evolving private fund industry, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has introduced the Private Fund Adviser Rule. Designed to address concerns related to investor harm, fraud, deception, manipulation, and conflicts of interest, this rule has far-reaching implications for private fund advisers and investors alike. In this article, we will explore the motivations behind the SEC’s release of this rule, its provisions and scope, and how the industry has responded to this regulatory development.

The SEC’s Motivation: Protecting Investors in a Changing Landscape

The Private Fund Adviser Rule is rooted in the SEC’s commitment to safeguarding the interests of private fund investors. The rule aims to accomplish this by increasing transparency and curbing practices that are contrary to the public interest and investor protection. These practices often stem from a lack of transparency, conflicts of interest, or governance deficiencies within the private fund industry.

The importance of this rule becomes evident when considering the following factors:

  1. Rapid Growth of the Industry: Over the past decade, the private fund industry has experienced explosive growth. According to the SEC, Assets under management (AUM) for private funds have surged by approximately 170%, reaching a staggering $26.6 trillion. Concurrently, the number of private funds has ballooned by over 220%, with over 101 thousand funds now in existence.
  2. Broad Investor Reach: The influence of private funds extends well beyond qualified investors, as millions of individuals are indirectly exposed to these funds through their participation in public and private pension plans, endowments, foundations, and retirement plans. The SEC believes that the need for transparency in such a diverse and far-reaching industry is paramount.

Key Provisions and Scope of the Private Fund Adviser Rule

The Private Fund Adviser Rule imposes specific provisions on both registered private fund advisers and private fund advisers not registered with the SEC:

For Registered Private Fund Advisers:

  1. Quarterly Statement Rule: Advisers must provide investors with quarterly disclosures about the fees, expenses, and expected performance of their private fund investments.
  2. Private Fund Audit Rule: An annual audit conducted by an independent, PCAOB-registered firm, in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), is required to ensure accurate financial reporting.
  3. Adviser-Led Secondaries Rule: Advisers involved in structuring and leading secondary transactions must obtain a fairness or independent valuation opinion.

For All Private Fund Advisers (including those not registered with the SEC):

  1. Restricted Activities Rule: This provision requires either pre- or post-disclosure, or outright majority consent for various adviser activities, including treatment of examination fees, compensation clawbacks, and borrowing from clients.
  2. Preferential Treatment Rule: Advisers are prohibited from granting certain investors preferential redemption or information rights that materially adversely affect other investors without written disclosure.

For All Registered Advisers (private or public):

  1. Compliance Rule: All SEC-registered advisers must document their annual review of compliance policies and procedures in writing.

A Deeper Dive into the Adviser-Led Secondaries Rule

The SEC’s adviser-led secondaries rule requires SEC-registered advisers to satisfy certain requirements if they initiate a transaction that offers private fund investors the option between selling all or a portion of their interests in the private fund and converting or exchanging them for new interests in another vehicle advised by the adviser or any of its related persons (an “adviser-led secondary transaction”). Such requirements include:

  • Obtaining either a fairness or valuation opinion from an independent provider and distribute this before the election due date.
  • Disclosing in writing any material business relationships with the independent opinion provider within the last two years.

This does not apply to tender offers that allow investors to retain their current exposure. However, it incentivizes advisers to offer investors more choices and flexibility.

The Rule also requires valuations to be obtained from “an independent opinion provider” who is defined as a person providing fairness opinions or valuation opinions in the ordinary course of business and not related to the adviser. This ensures expertise in valuing various types of assets.

Industry Reactions and Legal Challenges

The SEC’s proposal for the Private Fund Adviser Rule elicited a range of responses, both in support and opposition. Dissenting voices expressed concerns that additional regulations might stifle innovation, raise expenses, and negatively impact the economic environment for venture capital and start-up companies. The introduction of “grandfathering” provisions in the final rule aimed to address some of these concerns, allowing legacy contracts to remain intact.

Soon after the rule’s finalization, several financial industry trade associations initiated legal action against the SEC, alleging that the SEC had exceeded its statutory authority, among other claims. These associations include the Managed Funds Association, National Association of Private Fund Managers, National Venture Capital Association, American Investment Council, Alternative Investment Management Association, and Loan Syndications & Trading Association.

Organizations that are in support of the new private fund rules include the Institutional Limited Partners Association, Council of Institutional Investors, Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst Association, and multiple public retirement and pension funds and state investment boards.

The SEC is defending its by-the-book rulemaking procedures as it remains focused on its aim of increasing transparency and reducing conflicts of interest in the private funds sector. In February 2024, Federal Court judges debated the SEC’s oversight authority as it pertains to the private funds industry. While the panel expressed some concerns about the SEC’s overreach, there was also uncertainty as to whether the plaintiffs’ argument was broad enough for the rule to be blocked in full. The parties have requested a decision by May 31st. 

Transition Periods for Compliance

The Private Fund Adviser Rule was approved on August 23, 2023, and compliance periods vary depending on the specific provisions:

  • Quarterly Statement Rule and Private Fund Audit Rule: 18 months.
  • Adviser-Led Secondaries Rule, Preferential Treatment Rule, and Restricted Activities Rule:
    • Advisers with less than $1.5 billion in private funds under management: 18 months.
    • Advisers with $1.5 billion or more in private funds under management: 12 months.
  • Amended Advisers Compliance Rule: 60 days.

The Current Landscape

As the industry awaits the outcome of the court arguments, VRC sees that its clients are not waiting for a resolution. Instead, clients are considering how they must change their valuation cycles and shift their reporting to adjust for the coming 45-day mandate. We also have observed the emergence of third-party vendors developing various reporting solutions that could assist advisers in meeting the SEC’s extensive periodic reporting requirements, which we see as another clear indication that the new requirements of the rules package will likely take effect as planned.

Considering the anecdotal evidence from our client conversations, we recommend that fund managers consult with their advisors and third-party independent valuation advisors now to ensure they are ready for compliance – even if the SEC is made to consider rule adjustments by the court’s decisions. From VRC’s viewpoint, we know that added and increasing scrutiny is here to stay as, increasingly, asset managers have been under pressure from LPs, boards, auditors, and regulators. Helping to ensure best practices are in place ahead of continuing, coming rule changes is paramount to helping our clients maintain confidence in valuations, save staff time, and reduce costs in the long run.

Conclusion

The Private Fund Adviser Rule represents a significant step towards the SEC’s efforts in attempting to enhance transparency and protecting the interests of investors in the private fund industry. It addresses the unique challenges posed by the industry’s rapid growth and the broad reach of private funds into various investment vehicles. While industry stakeholders have voiced concerns and legal challenges have been raised, the rule’s ultimate impact on investor protection and market integrity remains to be seen as it is implemented and enforced in the coming years.


Subscribe to VRC Communications

Get the resources you need to make informed decisions about your financial and tax reporting requirements.

Subscribers receive first access to VRC’s thought leadership white papers, published articles, events and industry reports.

Tags: